• via Alberto da Giussano, 26, 20145 Milano
  • +39 02 4003 1253
  • info@studiolegalebianucci.it
  • Criminal Lawyer, Family Lawyer, Divorce Lawyer

Fraudulent Bankruptcy: Analysis of the Sentence of the Court of Cassation, Criminal Section V, No. 509 of 2023

The recent ruling by the Court of Cassation, Criminal Section V, No. 509 of January 10, 2023, provides significant insights into the criminal liability of directors in cases of fraudulent bankruptcy. In this specific case, A.A. was convicted for the transfer without compensation of a business branch during the bankruptcy of his company, highlighting the distinction between legitimate and illegal management of businesses.

Context and Course of the Trial

The Court of Appeal of Bologna had initially reduced the sentence imposed on A.A. for fraudulent bankruptcy but could not refrain from confirming the criminal liability of the defendant. The accusation was based on concrete evidence showing the transfer of crucial business assets to (Omissis) Ltd, a company linked to him, without any compensation.

  • De facto management of the bankrupt company.
  • Transfer without compensation of business assets.
  • Overlap of clients and employees between the two companies.
The transfer of a business branch that makes it no longer possible to pursue the corporate purpose constitutes the crime of fraudulent bankruptcy.

Legal Principles and Implications

The Court reiterated that fraudulent bankruptcy is established even in the absence of adequate compensation for the transfer of assets. This aspect is crucial for understanding the responsibilities of directors and the necessity for transparent and lawful business management. The decision aligns with established case law in the field, which stipulates that any operation that harms creditors is punishable under criminal law.

Furthermore, the ruling clarified that holding the position of director does not exempt one from liability in cases of illegal management. A.A. had played an active role in the management of the company, which made his responsibility in the diversion of assets evident.

Conclusions

The ruling of the Court of Cassation No. 509 of 2023 emphasizes the importance for directors to always act in compliance with the law and the interests of creditors. The implications of this ruling are significant not only for A.A. but for all economic operators, who must be aware of the criminal consequences of improper management of their businesses. Transparency and fairness must be at the core of business management to avoid incurring criminal sanctions and reputational harm.