• via Alberto da Giussano, 26, 20145 Milano
  • +39 02 4003 1253
  • info@studiolegalebianucci.it
  • Criminal Lawyer, Family Lawyer, Divorce Lawyer

Jurisdiction and Competence in Judgment No. 49354 of 2023: Analysis of the Conflict between Courts

Judgment No. 49354 issued by the Supreme Court of Cassation on September 6, 2023, addresses a crucial issue in criminal law: the conflict of competence between courts concerning money laundering and negligent purchase offenses. This case highlights the complexities of Italian criminal jurisdiction and the practical implications of legal decisions.

The Conflict of Competence and the Involved Parties

The conflict of competence was raised by the Preliminary Investigating Judge (G.I.P.) of the Brescia Court following a declaration of incompetence made by the Review Court of Milan. The central issue concerned the territorial relevance of the preventive seizure against the defendants B.B. and A.A., accused of crimes related to money laundering, particularly in light of an associative crime.

The crime of money laundering is committed at the moment and place where the transportation is carried out in a deceptive manner.

The G.I.P. of Brescia argued that, despite the connection between the various alleged offenses, the most serious crime, under Law No. 146 of 2006, only concerned some of the defendants, leading to confusion regarding competence. However, the Cassation confirmed the competence of the G.I.P. of Brescia, establishing that the conflict of competence should be resolved in favor of the latter.

The Implications of the Judgment

Judgment No. 49354 reaffirms some fundamental principles regarding jurisdiction. Among these:

  • The connection between offenses is not always sufficient to determine a single jurisdiction, especially when the most serious crime involves only some individuals.
  • Money laundering is completed at the place and moment when the deceptive economic operation takes place.
  • The principle of territoriality is fundamental in determining jurisdictional competence.

The Court also referenced previous case law, emphasizing that the commission of the crime of money laundering occurs at the location where the deceptive effect is realized, confirming the importance of the correct application of criminal procedural norms.

Conclusions

In conclusion, Judgment No. 49354 of 2023 represents an important reference point for understanding the dynamics of legal competence in Italian criminal law. The decision of the Supreme Court clarifies the rules to follow in case of conflicts of competence, providing valuable guidance for legal professionals. Clarity on these aspects is essential to ensure a fair and just process, avoiding procedural stagnation that can compromise the defendants' right to defense.