• via Alberto da Giussano, 26, 20145 Milano
  • +39 02 4003 1253
  • info@studiolegalebianucci.it
  • Criminal Lawyer, Family Lawyer, Divorce Lawyer

Exploitation of Prostitution: Commentary on the Judgment of the Italian Supreme Court, Criminal Section III, No. 2056 of 2024

The recent ruling of the Supreme Court, No. 2056 of 2024, provides an important opportunity for reflection on issues related to the exploitation of prostitution. The Court examined the case of three defendants accused of exploitation and facilitation of prostitution, analyzing the evidence presented and the arguments of the defenses. In this article, we will seek to clarify the key points of the ruling and their significance in the Italian legal context.

The Context of the Ruling

The criminal proceedings involved three defendants, including D. A., B. B., and C. C., accused of managing prostitution activities through the leasing of properties to women engaged in such practices. The Court of Appeal of Lecce had confirmed the conviction of D. A. and B. B. for the exploitation of prostitution, while acquitting C. C. due to lack of sufficient evidence. However, the Supreme Court deemed the appeals of D. A. and C. C. unfounded, while it annulled the conviction of B. B. for the offense of facilitation.

The Court clarified that the offense of exploitation of prostitution is established only if there is a direct economic profit deriving from the activity of prostitution and not simply from the leasing of properties.

The Court's Reasoning

  • The Court emphasized that exploitation of prostitution occurs when the defendant receives an excessive payment compared to the normal market cost for the services provided.
  • It was highlighted that merely renting a property to a prostitute does not constitute a crime, unless additional services are provided that may constitute direct assistance to the prostitution activity.
  • The ruling reiterated that criminal responsibility can arise only if there is a clear intent to exploit; mere awareness of the prostitution activity is not sufficient.

Legal Implications

This ruling has significant implications in the Italian legal landscape. First of all, it clarifies the boundaries between legitimate leasing and illegal exploitation, establishing that the subjective element is crucial for the configuration of the crime. The Court thus drew a clear line between legitimate entrepreneurial activity and illicit activity, providing an important point of reference for future similar cases.

Furthermore, the ruling reaffirms the importance of a critical evaluation of the evidence, emphasizing that the interpretation of wiretaps and testimonies must be carried out with rigor and consistency, avoiding hasty conclusions.

Conclusions

In summary, the ruling No. 2056 of the Supreme Court of 2024 represents a significant step in defining the legal boundaries of the exploitation of prostitution. It reaffirms the principle that criminal responsibility must be based on concrete evidence and on a rigorous interpretation of the defendants' conduct. The clarity of the reasoning provided by the Court offers useful guidance for lawyers and legal scholars, as well as for individuals involved in similar situations.