Order No. 10430 of 2024: Clarifications on Professional Fees and Waiver of Rights

The recent order no. 10430, issued on April 17, 2024, by the Court of Cassation, offers significant insights for understanding the qualification of payment requests by professionals. In particular, the case of M. (MARCHI LUCA) v. G. highlighted the delicacy of the issue regarding the waiver of professional fees and the correct interpretation of communications sent during the proceedings.

The Context of the Ruling

The Court ruled on the validity of a letter requesting payment "in settlement of all amounts due up to that date". It is essential to understand that, in the absence of a clear intention from the professional to waive their rights, such communication should not be considered as a waiver of the fees owed. This principle is vitally important for legal professionals and their clients, as it establishes clear limits on the possibility of fragmenting the unity of professional service.

The Meaning of the Maxim

In general. The letter containing the request for payment "in settlement of all amounts due up to that date" (in this case sent during the proceedings), in the absence of a more unequivocal waiving intention from the professional, does not take on dispositive value and does not constitute a waiver of any further claims and specific rights in execution of the sponsorship mandate, as it is not permissible to fragment the unity of the professional service.

This maxim emphasizes the importance of clear and unequivocal communication from the professional. If the intentions of waiver are not explicitly stated, the mere sending of a payment request cannot be interpreted as a concession of rights. This principle is based on the relevant regulations, such as the Civil Code in articles 2233 and 2234, which govern professional fees and the methods of fulfilling obligations.

Implications for Professionals

The implications of this order are manifold:

  • Need for clear and detailed communications to avoid misunderstandings.
  • Recognition of the unity of the professional service, which cannot be fragmented without a clear intention from the professional.
  • Importance of proper management of payment requests during the course of a dispute.

These elements are essential not only for lawyers but also for their clients, who must be aware of their rights and the methods for managing expectations regarding fees.

Conclusions

In conclusion, order no. 10430 of 2024 represents an important step forward in the clarity of professional relationships and the protection of professionals' rights. It reminds us of the importance of clear communication and the need to formalize one's intentions regarding the fees owed. This not only protects the rights of the professional but also ensures greater transparency in the relationships between lawyers and clients.

Bianucci Law Firm