Civil Liability and Damage from Custody: Analysis of the Cass. Civ., Ord. No. 4288/2024
The ruling of the Court of Cassation No. 4288 of 2024 offers significant insights into the civil liability of public administrations, particularly regarding damages caused by public works. In this article, we will explore the key points of the decision, analyzing the implications for citizens and public administrations.
The Context of the Ruling
The case originates from a dispute between A.A. and the Municipality of Gragnano, as well as the Campania Region, regarding the damages suffered by a property owned by A.A. following the collapse of a retaining wall. The Court of Appeal of Naples had initially acknowledged the Municipality's liability for the damage caused by the collapse but denied compensation for further damages deemed unnecessary.
Principles of Liability and Custody
The liability of the custodian is based not on a legal title but on the ability to exercise de facto power over the custodied object.
One of the key points of the ruling concerns the application of Art. 2051 of the Civil Code, which establishes the liability of the custodian for damages caused by the object in custody. The Court emphasized that, in this case, the damage claimed was not directly caused by the collapse but by the manner in which the restoration work was carried out, which was performed by the Region and not by the Municipality. This aspect is crucial as it highlights how the absence of de facto power over the asset by the Municipality excludes its liability.
Procedural Aspects and Conclusions
- The Court accepted the second reason of the main appeal, considering that there was an omission in examining a decisive fact, namely the need for consolidation works on the property.
- The Municipality successfully appealed, establishing that it was not liable for the damages caused by the restoration works.
- The case was referred back to the Court of Appeal for a new assessment of the compensable damages, taking into account the geomorphological conditions of the property.
Conclusions
Ruling No. 4288/2024 of the Court of Cassation represents an important reflection on the liability of public administrations in relation to damages from custodied objects. It highlights the need for a thorough analysis of the execution methods of public works and the rights of citizens to be compensated for damages suffered. This case underscores the importance of clarifying the boundaries of liability in complex contexts and provides a significant precedent for future disputes regarding civil liability and public works.
Bianucci Law Firm
We constantly follow regulatory and jurisprudential developments, offering updated analyses and innovative solutions. We share legal developments to foster a more informed legal culture.
Latest Articles
Categories
- administrative law (3)
- aesthetic damage (1)
- biological damage (1)
- bullying (3)
- burden of proof (1)
- case law (15)
- civil law (47)
- civil liability (40)
- civil_law (1)
- civil_liability (5)
- commercial law (1)
- compensation for damages (9)
- compensations (1)
- consumer law (1)
- contracts (1)
- Court of Cassation (1)
- Covid-19 (2)
- criminal law (5)
- criminal liability (1)
- Damage assessment (3)
- damage compensation (2)
- damages compensation (38)
- damages_compensation (10)
- employer_liability (1)
- employer_responsibility (1)
- European law (1)
- family law (4)
- family_law (3)
- financial law (1)
- health law (19)
- healthcare (2)
- healthcare law (1)
- healthcare liability (6)
- INAIL compensation (1)
- informed consent (2)
- inheritance law (1)
- insurance (5)
- insurance law (1)
- insurance_law (2)
- jurisdiction (1)
- jurisprudence (11)
- justice (1)
- labor law (21)
- labor_law (5)
- law of evidence (1)
- lease (1)
- legal expenses (1)
- liability (2)
- medical liability (13)
- medical malpractice (3)
- minors' rights (1)
- moral damage (3)
- neighboring rights (1)
- noise pollution (1)
- non-economic damage (1)
- Non-pecuniary damage (4)
- Occupational Disease (1)
- occupational diseases (4)
- occupational safety (1)
- occupational_diseases (1)
- prescription (1)
- prison system (1)
- private law (1)
- professional liability (19)
- property rights (1)
- protection of workers (1)
- protection of workers' rights (1)
- public administration (1)
- public administration liability (1)
- right to health (3)
- right to life (1)
- road accidents (5)
- self-determination (1)
- social security (2)
- social security law (1)
- statute of limitations (1)
- tax law (3)
- Tax litigation (1)
- technical consultancy (1)
- testimonial_evidence (1)
- tort law (4)
- tort liability (1)
- tourism law (1)
- wildlife (1)
- worker dignity (1)
- worker protection (1)
- workers' protection (1)
- workplace accidents (2)
- Workplace injuries (3)
- workplace safety (1)
Tags
Accident accident prevention law accidents accountant acoustic emissions active legitimacy art. 141 Insurance Code article 2087 civil code asbestos asbestos exposure biological damage blood transfusions burden of proof case law case_law Cassation Cassation ruling Catanzaro court catastrophic damage causal link childbirth civil law civil liability cohabitation compensatio lucri cum damno compensation compensation action compensation for damages compensation tables congenital malformations Consob Consumer Code contagion contractual liability corporate liability Court of Appeal Court of Cassation Court of Cassation 19744/2014 Covid-19 criminal law criminal liability damage assessment damage compensation damage evidence damages damages assessment damages compensation death diagnostic errors differential damage disability insurance dismissal emotional bond emotional bonds employer liability employer_liability equity evidence failure to supervise family law guidelines gynecologist HCV health law healthcare liability heating systems heirs hepatitis C virus I.N.A.I.L. iatrogenic damage iatrogenic injury INAIL income tax indemnity indemnity law informed consent injury from fall insurance insurance coverage insurance policies insurance policy intentional injuries joint liability judgment judgment 3767/2018 jurisdiction jurisprudence labor law landlord liability law law 194 legal expenses Legislative Decree 81/2008 legitimate reliance liability Lyell syndrome maintenance of public works malpractice Marche Region medical expenses medical liability medical malpractice medical negligence medical record mesothelioma Milan Court Milan ruling Ministry of Justice mobbing monetary penalty moral damage municipal liability Naples negligent arson newborn non-economic damage non-economic_damage non-pecuniary damage nosocomial infection nosocomial infections oath occupational disease occupational diseases occupational health package travel parental damage parental liability parental supervision passengers pension personal injuries personal injury pets premature birth professional liability property rights psychological suffering public administration public liability refusal of transfusion remedy Revenue Agency right to compensation right to health right to life road accident road accidents road traffic accidents ruling ruling 1361/2014 ruling 2023 ruling 5947 ruling Court of Naples safety safety of systems safety regulations self-determination settlement statute of limitations strepitus fori substitution Supreme Court Supreme Court 2023 Supreme Court ruling Supreme Court ruling 2023 surgical intervention survivor's pension survivors' pension tax law taxation technical consulting technical liability testimonial evidence tort liability traffic accident unjust detention unlawful occupation usufruct VAT water damage wildlife witness testimony Work work environment work-related liability. work-related stress worker health workers' rights workplace accident workplace accidents workplace injuries workplace safety