Personal Injuries and Medical Liability: Analysis of the Cassation Court Judgment No. 12968 of 2021

The recent ruling by the Court of Cassation, No. 12968 of 2021, offers an important reflection on the responsibilities of doctors in cases of personal injuries. In this case, the Court examined the conduct of two surgeons involved in a hysterectomy that resulted in significant complications for the patient, U.D. The ruling analyzes the distinction between diagnostic error and liability, emphasizing the importance of adequate clinical assessment.

The Case Under Judgment

U.D. underwent surgery for suspected endometriosis, but the consequences were severe. Surgeons M.G.B. and M.M. were accused of operating without conducting the necessary diagnostic investigations. The Court of Appeal of Cagliari upheld the acquittal of the two doctors, arguing that negligence or imprudence could not be proven. However, the civil party appealed this decision, bringing the matter to the Cassation Court.

The Conclusions of the Court of Cassation

The Cassation Court annulled the appeal ruling, highlighting some motivational deficiencies and the need for a more in-depth analysis. In particular, the Court emphasized the importance of conducting diagnostic investigations before proceeding with a risky surgical intervention. It stated that the doctor must always adopt a more rigorous diagnostic procedure to avoid risks to the patient's health.

The doctor has the obligation to gather all necessary information from the patient and other reliable sources to ensure the correctness of the surgical treatment performed.

Implications for Healthcare Professionals

This ruling carries significant implications for healthcare professionals. It is essential that doctors carefully assess the possibility of conducting diagnostic tests before any intervention, especially when there are doubts about the diagnosis. Additionally, the importance of proper clinical documentation cannot be underestimated, as it serves as crucial evidence in the event of litigation.

Conclusions

The Cassation Court ruling No. 12968 of 2021 represents an important step towards greater accountability for doctors. It highlights how caution and diligence are essential in the diagnostic and therapeutic process, and how the failure to observe such principles can lead to severe consequences for both the patient and the professional. Jurisprudence continues to evolve in this area, indicating the need for an increasingly careful and meticulous approach by physicians.

Bianucci Law Firm