Deposit of Another's Property: Analysis of Ordinance No. 16589 of 2024

The right of retention and sale of the deposited property, in case of non-payment of the consideration, is a topic of particular relevance in Italian civil law. With Ordinance No. 16589 of 13/06/2024, the Court of Cassation clarified important aspects regarding the deposit of another's property, highlighting the rights and duties of the depository and the owner of the property.

The Regulatory Context

Article 2756 of the Civil Code establishes that the depository has the right to retain the deposited property until payment of the consideration for the services rendered. This right also extends in cases where the deposited property belongs to a person other than the depositor, provided that the deposit has been previously authorized by the legitimate owner.

Deposit of another's property - Non-payment of the consideration - Right of retention and sale of the deposited property to the detriment of the owner - Existence - Conditions and limits. In the matter of deposit of another's property, the depository who has not been paid the consideration has the right to retain and have the deposited property sold, pursuant to Article 2756 of the Civil Code, even if it is owned by a person other than the depositor, if the deposit has been previously consented by the owner, barring the depository's bad faith.

Conditions of Applicability

It is essential to underline some conditions and limits that emerge from the ruling:

  • The deposit must have been previously consented by the owner of the property.
  • The depository must not act in bad faith.
  • The right of retention does not exclude any claims by the legitimate owner.

Conclusions

The ruling in question offers an important opportunity for reflection on the dynamics of asset liability and the correct exercise of rights in the case of deposit of another's property. It is crucial for professionals in the sector to understand how the rights of retention and sale can influence the relationships between depositors and owners, while ensuring a balance between the needs for asset protection and respect for others' rights.

Bianucci Law Firm