Shared custody and the best interest of the child: commentary on Cass. Civ. n. 21312/2022

The ruling of the Court of Cassation n. 21312 of 2022 is part of an important legal debate regarding the custody of children born out of wedlock. In particular, the Court clarified that shared custody should be considered the standard arrangement, even in the presence of conflicts between parents. This principle is of fundamental importance, as it emphasizes that the best interest of the child must always be at the center of judicial decisions.

The context of the ruling

The Court of Appeal of Palermo initially ordered the exclusive custody of the child to one parent, considering the conflict between the parties. However, the appeal filed by C.B. led to a reassessment of the situation, highlighting that there were insufficient elements to justify such a decision. The Court emphasized the necessity of adequate reasoning, which must demonstrate not only the suitability of the custodial parent but also the unsuitability of the other parent.

The Court reiterated that shared custody is the standard arrangement, even in cases of serious conflict between parents, unless it is detrimental to the best interest of the child.

Analysis of the decision

In its decision, the Court highlighted that conflict between parents should not automatically exclude shared custody. The reasons behind the decision for exclusive custody were inadequate, as they did not take into account the responsibilities of both parents in creating a favorable environment for the child. The ruling thus underscores the importance of constructive dialogue between parents, which should be promoted even in conflict situations.

  • Shared custody as the standard arrangement.
  • Conflict does not exclude shared custody.
  • Importance of dialogue between parents for the child's welfare.

Conclusions

In conclusion, the ruling of the Court of Cassation n. 21312/2022 represents an important step forward in protecting the child's right to dual parenthood. It reaffirms that shared custody should prevail unless there is concrete evidence of harm to the child. It is essential that parents, even in conflict situations, commit to maintaining open and constructive dialogue to ensure the well-being and peaceful development of their children.

Bianucci Law Firm