Consensual Separation: Analysis of Judgment No. 20034 of 2024

Judgment No. 20034 of 2024, issued by the Court of Cassation, provides an important reflection on the methods of consensual separation between spouses and the legal implications of the resulting agreements. In particular, the Court focused on the distinction between the necessary and contingent content of the agreements, a crucial aspect for understanding the validity and modifiability of the stipulations made.

Essential and Contingent Content of Agreements

According to the ruling, the agreements of spouses in the case of consensual separation present an essential content, aimed at ensuring compliance with the duties of marital solidarity in the period immediately following the separation. This content may be supplemented by contingent stipulations, intended to regulate property situations that the parties no longer wish to maintain.

Consensual separation - Necessary and contingent content - Distinction - Relevance - Consequences. In the matter of consensual separation, the agreements of the spouses have an essential content, aimed at fulfilling the duties of marital solidarity for the time immediately following the separation, to which a contingent one may be added, aimed at regulating property situations that the parties are no longer interested in maintaining; only the essential stipulations can be revoked and modified pursuant to Article 710 of the Italian Civil Procedure Code (later replaced by Article 473-bis.29 of the same code) and are intended to be superseded by the divorce decree, while the contingent ones follow the discipline of legal transactions and cannot be revoked or modified.

The Consequences of Stipulations

The distinction between essential and contingent content has significant legal consequences. Essential stipulations, in fact, may be subject to modification or revocation based on Article 710 of the Civil Procedure Code and are intended to be superseded by the potential divorce decree. In contrast, contingent stipulations are subject to a different discipline and cannot be modified or revoked as easily.

Final Considerations

This ruling serves as an important guide for spouses contemplating a consensual separation. Understanding the differences between the various types of agreements is crucial to avoiding future conflicts and ensuring that mutual rights and duties are respected. Therefore, it is always advisable to consult a legal expert for appropriate advice and for the drafting of clear and well-structured agreements.

Bianucci Law Firm