Plea Bargaining and Preliminary Hearing: Complete Guide

Introduction

In the Italian legal landscape, plea bargaining and the preliminary hearing are two fundamental institutions that can influence the course of a criminal proceeding. Understanding when and how to request plea bargaining, as well as the current regulations, is essential for anyone involved in a legal proceeding.

What is Plea Bargaining?

Plea bargaining, or application of the sentence at the request of the parties, is an agreement between the defendant and the public prosecutor, which provides for a reduction of the sentence in exchange for a guilty plea. This institution is governed by Article 444 of the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure and represents an alternative procedure to the ordinary trial.

"Plea bargaining allows one to avoid a lengthy trial, obtaining a quick judgment and a reduced sentence."

When is it possible to request Plea Bargaining?

  • During the preliminary hearing up to the declaration of the opening of the first-instance trial.
  • For offenses that carry a prison sentence of no more than 5 years, including conversion to a monetary penalty.
  • When both parties, prosecution and defense, agree on the proposed sentence.

The Procedure of the Preliminary Hearing

The preliminary hearing is the moment when the judge assesses the validity of the charges and decides whether to proceed to trial for the defendant. During this phase, it is possible to present the plea bargaining request. The preliminary hearing is held behind closed doors and involves the examination of available evidence, allowing the judge to decide on the fate of the trial.

Advantages of Plea Bargaining

  • Reduction of the sentence by up to one third.
  • Quick conclusion of the proceeding.
  • Avoids the public exposure of a trial.

Conclusion

Plea bargaining and the preliminary hearing are valuable tools in Italian criminal law, capable of offering quick and less burdensome solutions for those involved in a criminal proceeding. If you need further information or assistance with a specific case, do not hesitate to contact Studio Legale Bianucci. Our team of experts is here to help you navigate the complex world of criminal justice.

Contact Us